Clicky

X

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get the State of Digital Newsletter
Join an elite group of marketers receiving the best content in their mailbox
* = required field
Daily Updates

Why I Hate WordPress Websites!

28 November 2013 BY

192 Flares Twitter 96 Facebook 36 Google+ 31 LinkedIn 9 Buffer 20 Email -- StumbleUpon 0 Pin It Share 0 Filament.io 192 Flares ×

Woah! Your probably think did I read the title of this post correct? Well no you didn’t! but let me make one thing clear, I’m an avid WordPress fan and use it on a daily basis not only for my own websites and for many clients. Since its inception as “WordPress” in 2003 I was a reasonably early adopter using for my own blogs in 2004 and 2005 and I have installed and insane amount of WordPress installs over the years. So what am I taking about? WordPress is great! Its used by companies such as “The New York Times”, “The BBC” or celebrities such as “Snoop Dogg” to “Usain Bolt”.

The trouble comes down to one of its best assets, the fact it is Open Source and so many people have adopted it.

So why do I hate WordPress?

I’ll be honest I don’t hate WordPress I hate WordPress Developers! You may have ready my post “Shouldn’t my developer know SEO?” and this is the type of developers I’m talking about; it far too easy to find someone who develops WordPress websites, but there needs to be a clear distinction between developing a WordPress Website and Developing a Good WordPress Website. Let me expand on this and talk about where my frustrations come from.

Hygiene Factors

I have come to learn that any website should abide by certain hygiene factors especially these days for example:

  1. Security
  2. Scalability
  3. Speed
  4. Usability / Conversion
  5. Basic SEO
  6. Manageability
  7. Responsive / Mobile
  8. Tracking
  9. Test

My main problem with 90%* of WordPress developers is that they take none of the above into consideration, OK well for many WordPress installations they are singular blogs where the owner manages and makes all the changes themselves, however most company sites should be able to be picked up by anyone and I find myself continually battling against this.

WordPress Setup

The most common mistake I find is that developers put WordPress sites live without un-ticking the box to let Google spider them.

discourage search engines

Security (Vulnerabilities)

All sites can be subject to vulnerabilities, however one thing about WordPress is its common usage, I asked Irish Wonder for her opinion having seen her present on the subject before, she advised.

Many issues, however, are not platform specific for WordPress only – e.g. any site owner can set permissions to 777, even for a static site not using any CMS. Any CMS can have search results indexable (which is one of the security flaws covered in my slide deck). Same goes for any CMS that is extendable with plugins – theoretically, any third party plugin can add more security flaws. The main risk with WordPress, IMHO, is, like other popular CMS’s, it is a frequent target for those looking for security flaws because once you find one you can use it so many times. Which, of course, does not make bespoke sites more secure, just less likely to be targeted.

In June 2013, it was found that some of the 50 most downloaded WordPress plugins were vulnerable to common Web attacks such as SQL injection and XSS. – Wikipedia with this in mind its no wonder that when I asked Yoast (a prolific WordPress Plugin Developer) about his biggest gripe he advised:

Most annoying thing? Installing unvetted plugins from outside of WordPress.org

If you want to know more about WordPress Security you can also take a look at the slides from Bastian Grimm at SASCON 2013:

Scalability

My Next Gripe with WordPress Developers is scaling up a project, one great thing about WordPress is that it can be scaled up and reasonably easily… Wait! That depends on on if its been developed in a way to allow scalability.  My main tips are avoid:

  • Pages which use a template to pull in individual pages – I have seen this many times where a developer creates a fancy template where you can not edit any of the text in the actual WordPress page, in fact it will call an ID in the template and pull in text from another page created. Not only does this potentially create duplicate content, it defeats the point of using WordPress in many ways.

Themes and Site Design

I often find I’m in the WordPress admin for a page and the site has been designed to show to different sections of content with the template, here a developer may use a plugin such as “Advanced Custom Fields” this allows  a user to then have various WYSIWYG blocks on the admin of a page, but it becomes UN-manageable and makes scalability difficult as instead of one WYSIWYG editor you know have five or ten all pulling from the database.

Speed

I get simply annoyed with the fact that someone would design a website and not optimize the web development, I’m not saying you have to use a caching plugin or a CDN (although preferable) but when a theme is designed, why leave CSS and JavaScript untidy? A business will pay sometimes thousands of pounds for a website and then someone like myself will come and recode it! Why? we created brochure websites in 2002, i mean come on people have some pride!

Usability and Conversion

Now if you design websites you should design for the user, regardless of how pretty a website can be if it doesn’t generate leads or sale its useless* (*unless you do simply want a brochure website) . You don’t have to be an expert in conversion or usability to know that text colour should be a contrast from the back ground, or that navigation should direct a user to where they want to go. If a page is created you should always think:

  • How will someone get here?
  • Where will they go from here?
  • How do they return to where they have come from?

Fundamental SEO

Again in my mind if your are a WordPress Web Developer you should understand at minimum the fundamental concepts of on page SEO which are:

  • Title
  • Heading (H1)
  • Content

WordPress is great because it can create search engine friendly URLs and generally gets spidered pretty quickly when a post is published, however please please when you develop a template file include a H1 (heading) tag, this is all I ask…

Of course there are many other things you can do regarding WordPress and SEO, I’m not going to go through them in this post, but one other gripe is that developers are very quick to install an SEO plugin, however if all you do is install it and then leave the same duplicate title on every page then you just shouldn’t! Leave it alone, let word press use the default titles and at least have some originality and uniqueness to the titles.

Manageability

WordPress is a Content Management System (CMS), you can add users with different privileges so many people can update posts, sales messaging etc, so why design a Theme than has static content which can’t be edited unless you are a developer?

Tip: Also think about using something like Google Tag Manager, this allows you to manage, analytics, Adwords conversion, remarketing code all in one place without access to FTP’s (Once the code has been placed), making updated code easily and adding new conversions for Adwords and not having to rely on a developer.

Responsive / Mobile

If you develop a theme so it is responsive then at least test it, See example below.

responsive-photo

The other key point is testing; just because a theme is responsive doesn’t mean it will work better than a non responsive theme, I would personally split test the responsive version against the original (non responsive), I do appreciate that this may not be down to the developer to make this decision.

Tracking

I wrote a post a two months ago about tracking and testing your contact forms so all I ask as bare minimum MR WordPress developers is please ask your client if you should install some form of analytics and please check it and the forms works.

Testing

Above all if you are a developer or an agency which lay claim to WordPress Development (Or any development) please take a little pride and test what you have created!  I recommend at least spidering the site to find any common faults (You could use IIS Toolkit (Free), Screaming Frog (Free & Paid), Xenu (Free), Alwebsite Analyser(Paid))  and of course test the forms.

End of Rant?

Please excuse if it seems that I have shoe horned all WordPress Developers with the same hat, I have just had many frustrations having dealt with 50-60 different WordPress Developers and Agencies and having to pick up the pieces, but is this just me? No, I spoke with Alex Moss of Firecask and Shane Jones who both co-founded Peadig a WordPress Theme built on the Bootstrap Framework, this is what they had to say:

Alex Moss

I love WordPress. It’s my CMS of choice and I advise most of my clients to use it. Is it perfect? Far from it, but it’s the best choice and there’s a reason it powers 26% of all websites. For me, weaknesses usually stem from poor coding. This poor coding can come from either:

  • Bad custom theme development
  • Bad paid theme purchased from Joe Bloggs
  • Bad plugins

The issue is that none of those 3 things help you unless you know how to look at code and what to look for. I did give a few tips in an article I wrote a few months ago. To me, it’s about trusting the developer most of all, and doing your homework on plugins or themes you intend to buy.

As a developer who never really advertised himself as a developer at the beginning of my career, most of my WordPress creations are a result of someone else doing a poor job of something I think I could do better.

Shane Jones

Regarding Setup
In the setup phase there are a few key things that should always be done. If you’re not the most experienced WordPress developer or you may have skimmed the documentation, you’ll miss an important part about changing Security Keys. These are used for encryption on your WordPress site and as it says on the codex itself:

 A secret key makes your site harder to hack and access harder to crack by adding random elements to the password.

This is usually the first thing I do when in my config files and ideally you would make these all different values for the 8 different variables there.  Another good issue a lot of people miss in setup is changing your admin username from admin to something less easy to guess. WordPress even recommend this themselves. (Source: http://codex.wordpress.org/Brute_Force_Attacks ) The reason being that most of the brute force attacks that happen on WordPress happen through scripts trying to guess the password for the admin user.

Regarding Themes
My biggest annoyance with some free themes is some that actually don’t have some core css styles that WordPress requires. These styles can be found here http://codex.wordpress.org/CSS. Without these styles, which can be modified themselves, the page a user creates will not look the same as when they creating the page in the page editor.

Then there is testing, I have worked with some themes in the past that haven’t been tested well. When you create a theme you should really test every possibility of post or page that a user can create. Luckily there are some tools to help you with this. WordPress themselves have a Theme Testing export file that you can upload to your site. Personally I use tool called WPTest.io. These testing tools will create a number of posts, pages, categories, users in many forms. In the case of WPTest, you can click into the posts and it will tell you what you need to look for. Then its a case of tweaking those posts until everything looks great in your theme.

AUTHORED BY:
h

Neil Walker started working as an SEO in 2002 and rose to become Group CTO for Swedish Marketing Agency “Online Group” in 2010 he moved to consulting with agencies, in-house teams and PR companies. In 2014 he formalised this work and founded Made Notable Ltd a boutique digital consultancy based in Manchester, UK.
  • http://www.barryadams.co.uk/ Barry Adams

    It’s not so much WordPress that’s the problem, but – like you say – bad WordPress developers. Truth be told, that is an issue irrelevant to WordPress; whatever the most popular CMS is, there will be an abundance of bad developers who make crap websites with it. If ExpressionEngine was the CMS of choice, you’d have written ‘Why I Hate ExpressionEngine’ instead. ;)

    • Josh Barnett

      Agreed. This title is just click bait, which is all too common nowadays.

      • chrendz

        Click bait always defeats me

  • Giuseppe Pastore

    Agreeing with Barry Adams; very few specific WordPress problems and too much generic ones…

  • http://www.michaelrurupandersen.dk/ Michael Rurup Andersen

    Hi neil. Thanks for an very interesting article. Gave me a lot of food for thought. What CMS would you recommend instead of using WP?

    • http://alex-moss.co.uk/ Alex Moss

      I asked Mike Little (Co-Creator, WordPress) this at SAScon in May. He recommended Drupal. I agree with him (and I hate Drupal) although Magento usually wins for larger E Commerce sites

      • Hostile Negress

        Where’s Joomla in this discussion?

  • http://www.brosix.com/ Brosix

    You hit the nail on the head. Bad developers is what plagues a great publishing platform like WordPress or any other CMS for that matter. Nice Article!

  • Guest

    I wouldnt give WP any credit really at all. I’ve written my own CMS that worked better. The fact that WP completely forgets to include a function to keep is SQL clean is beyond me, and having to use 10 plugins just to manage other plugins, it’s a nightmare in infinite ways

    • scottrichardson

      Agreed. Custom solutions for the win.

  • http://imvictoriapratt.com Haydrion

    if you hate wordpress than why is this site in wordpress ?

    • http://www.shamontiel.com/ Shamontiel

      Did you bother to read the blog or just comment? Neil said at the beginning, “I’m an avid WordPress fan and use it on a daily basis.”

  • http://www.shamontiel.com/ Shamontiel

    I think you make some great points, especially about the plug-ins. But this blog needs to be proofed. From the first line down (ex. “Your probably think” should be “You’re probably thinking…,” there are quite a bit of typos. It takes away from an otherwise very intelligent op/ed.

  • TheBigOne

    I think all blogs suck equally! The internet is dead now not because of smartphones *which some if it is the reason* but because of crappy web developers that focus on automatic security or censoring people instead of fixing basic website problems many people will complain about and subsequently get ignored.

  • scottrichardson

    Custom, hand coded sites will always trump Word Press. We did a test and built the same site (visually, functionally) twice. Once with WordPress, once hand coded. The hand coded site would load two to three times faster for all pages and, not including the admin folder, had almost 70% less code. For me it’s about performance!

  • colinwiseman

    “there’s a reason it powers 26% of all websites” ~ cause it’s free to download and use, and WordPress.com gives free hosting if you can handle a non specific URL…or for only $30 a year hosting plus a nice URL!

    Doesn’t make it good. It is good. But it is not great. I hate the plugin architecture. So many plugins “run” on every page even when they won’t display on that page.

    WordPress (in my humble opinion) is absolutely perfect for the tiny to small (maybe medium) business with traffic in the low thousands or less. But when you start to get into needing tonnes of customisation, due to high traffic and business needs, you will find the people that have been using WordPress for years boke at the idea of paying the going rates for a high quality developer to fix it. And then you have to either rebuild the theme completely because so many bad wordpress developers make a lot of money on themeforest!

    Rant over for now :D

192 Flares Twitter 96 Facebook 36 Google+ 31 LinkedIn 9 Buffer 20 Email -- StumbleUpon 0 Pin It Share 0 Filament.io 192 Flares ×